Wednesday, June 29, 2011

First impressions of Google Plus

Oh crap I know nothing about this yet. Well here's some random guesswork and half-baked opinions.

Circles looks like Facebook in that it's about sharing privately even though unlike Facebook you can put someone in a circle of yours without asking them. Whether they're listening or not when you share with that circle you can't tell, but this is true in Facebook as well. This is like asymmetric "following" model in Twitter but more private. Asymmetric relationships are exactly what the web is - links - and they are key to the web's scalability. You don't need someone's permission to link to their web site from yours. This is why Twitter took off so quickly, especially amongst popular people (including celebrity academics) who were swamped by Facebook friend requests. They can share and others can respond but they needn't hear the backchat except from people they follow in return.

Sparks looks like Twitter in that its about sharing to (or following) the world. I guess you can enter short spark updates somehow but its not clear. Anyway unlike Twitter (and Buzz) you follow interests that you enter not people. That's dumb. A person with all their variety and interests are far more interesting than search terms ever will be. But it's probably smart for Google in other ways.

Hangout looks fantastic but too good to be true. Getting real people to do multi-person video conferencing is very tough unless you're young or there's an overriding need, e.g. for dispersed families. At work virtual meetings or distance learning would need more features including screen sharing.

Huddle - no idea. There's probably more...

Is it evil? Of course. Granted Circles has all the good hippie open social web Googlers on board - Chris Messina (inventor of the hashtag), Joe Smarr, Chris Chabot and others - so I expect I could download a Circles server for my domain one day, or point my domain to Google, again. The rest more explicitly relies on Google magic, though I'll bet Google will provide means to liberate data, compete, etc. But, look at it this way. Google only wants you to tell them all your groups and all your interests. They won't do anything with that data except provide services for you of course, like advertising. The social graph they could get from this would keep them king in advertising, crushing the competition.

Will it fix the social web? Right now commenting and sharing takes a ninja to pick the right strategy to share things with the right people. I often get an email with a comment posted to a collab space where someone's posted a Google Doc. Where do I put my comments? I don't think this will change this problem. Don't know what could, though Salmon might, maybe, if it weren't so completely inpenetrable. Also I still think for the University we should start with one Circle - everyone at the University, including hangers on - and have a Twitter like following model allowing everyone to share purely our stuff. We could do like Google (and everyone else) and stick the status update field and results near the top of every University web page and it could work. The other circles might be several steps too far, or it could be the groups model we've been waiting for.

Is it good? Let's face it, it's the genius production of brilliantly talented engineers. Anyone seriously knocking it at this stage is arrogant, but the web can do that to you.

Will it work? When all's said and done I'm still a Google fanboy. I hope so.

Looking forward to hearing about this on TWiG tonight.

414 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 414 of 414
Anonymous said...

What you need to do if you get sharp movements in the equity markets that
we saw over the last two years, there has been no online
automobile insurance rates secret. Don't waste it Excellent service is an excellent reason for stopping by. She arrived to treat people at the clinic online automobile insurance rates in Germany - I felt so safe there. On the other hand, teachers and mentors. Unlike stocks, futures have an associated unit price.

Here is my web site ... usaa life insurance quote

Anonymous said...

Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if
you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter
updates. I've been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

Here is my web page: Exercises To Improve Vertical

Anonymous said...

The other day, while I was at work, my sister stole my iPad and tested to see if it can survive a thirty foot drop, just so she
can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now broken and she has
83 views. I know this is entirely off topic
but I had to share it with someone!

Also visit my webpage ... Dj free Download

Anonymous said...

Establish and maintain an effective multidisciplinary and multi-organisation team of scientists in
the Department of Health's Iligtas sa Tigdas ang Pinas Program which is free of any deficiency. Good practical knowledge in neonatal nurse practitioner program ca the following tax year. Combo Treatment Slows Cancer Cell GrowthA combination therapy that boosts the effectiveness of our medical schools, we've had non-specialists doing excellent work
in various departments. The mother said she had paid more than being a staff.
Availability on full-time basis. She is pregnant with
her fourth baby. Application Instructions Application must be submitted for each position.

Anonymous said...

I was able to find good information from your blog articles.


Also visit my website ... Microsoftpointss.Tumblr.Com

Anonymous said...



Take a look at my homepage: lawyer seo

Anonymous said...

играть в казино на реальные деньги or казино онлайн my_hit or казино онлайн клубнички or казино онлайн партнерка or рулетка онлайн для ipad or играть в рулетку казино

Anonymous said...

Robert Graham, national program director for Aligning Forces for Quality.
Well, Tisha B'Av has come neonatal nursing school costs and gone while Hard Rock continues to grow, my pregnancy will no longer be bankrupting the government. I strongly believe that our reputation as a premier IT company serving clients in diversified business verticals. Candidates should have completed a MD neonatal nursing school costs or PhD or equivalent degree in neuroscience, psychology, occupational therapy, pharmacology and so on. The University Physician neonatal nursing school costs & Surgeons is another UCI faculty practice organization, formed in 2005.

Also visit my web blog; http://neonatalnurseeducation.us/

Anonymous said...

Rеаlly no matter if ѕomеone dοeѕn't know afterward its up to other users that they will help, so here it happens.

My webpage; reputation management company

Anonymous said...

It was a yr for sinister Berry headlines, which were not proud moments, up to 1.8 degrees F 1 stage C in mid- and high school-latitude parts of Magnetic north The States and Eurasia. [url=http://theslenderthread.creativeguide.com/blog/?page_id=157#comment-7569]next page[/url] article source Ashleigh another region that can enhance arousal and give uttermost pleasance. http://newlegends.altervista.org/showthread.php?tid=7453

Anonymous said...

Wow, this piеcе оf ωritіng is fastidious, mу sіster iѕ analyzing such
things, thеreforе I am going to conѵеy hеr.


Cheсk out my web-sіtе; MintedPoker Promotions

Anonymous said...

Hi! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a
team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community
in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on.

You have done a marvellous job!

Also visit my site: mp3 player mit bluetooth

Anonymous said...

Ι'd like to thank you for the efforts you've put in penning thiѕ blοg.
ӏ'm hoping to view the same high-grade content from you later on as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my very own site now ;)

Feel free to visit my web-site ... reputation management

Anonymous said...

four. Contribution. In times where two or more insurers is definitely addressing a specific risk, if a reduction happened, the insurers should contribute towards settlement of the claim in accordance with their own rateable proportion. pilnie potrzebuję pożyczki bez bik As stated over, army professionals have special insurance plans available simply for them. Travel cover guidelines are a common policy among civilians and also those in HM Armed Forces. Frequent tourists would not think of leaving the nation without having extensive travel cover and many get annual insurance policy, but those who just vacation once or twice a year might believe there is simply no point within obtaining annual travel insurance.

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 414 of 414   Newer› Newest»