Friday, June 25, 2010

The RSS Myth

There is a broad misconception that RSS is the answer to all your information problems. "Don't lock your information in web pages," they say, "that's so old-school. Set it free in RSS feeds, so intermediating web sites that are groovier than yours - or even your end-users directly - can 'mash it up' anywhere and in any way they choose." It's an easy get out. No need for information architecture. It'll all be mashed up anyway. Just stick RSS buttons on every page you can think of, and it's job done. I beg to disabuse this cosy view. RSS may be a great standard that has support across the web, but this may be masking the fact that in most cases RSS just isn't good enough, for these reasons:
  1. For public information, it's far better to use social networking.
  2. For private information, it's insecure.


Lets deal with RSS for public information first. How do end-users consume RSS feeds? Well non-techies probably try clicking on one of those RSS buttons on sites and following one of the plethora of buttons and sign up procedures for RSS reader services that follow, before getting quite confused. Perhaps their browser or mail reader will try to help them keep track of RSS feeds too, but then moving to a different computer will leave them confused all over again. So most people fall at the first hurdle. Even those who choose a great reader have to be pretty disciplined to stay in the habit of following most feeds, and that's because they're usually much too narrow. The typical RSS feeds that universities expose include departmental news stories, custom search results, new books in the library, etc. It looks good, but the results for even the most assiduous RSS consumer is a river of unexciting, unconnected, over-machined news that quickly begins to feel like a millstone around their neck. Much of this information would be better framed as pithy updates to be consumed in a timely way via (shudder!) email, or displayed in context in a web page (gasp!) that is connected to the content.
Perhaps the most intelligent use of RSS for public information is to use it to disseminate and collect must-read articles from quality blogs like this one (!). Meaty articles that you're happy to dip into in a different context, even offline, away from the bustle of your email inbox and your social media streams. This is the podcast model, where the easy collection of free radio or TV programs, say, via your RSS reader (e.g. iTunes) for consumption on your favourite personal device does lead to a great experience. With the advent of the iPad, perhaps we need a new word for RSS feeds focused on quality, iPad friendly, blog or magazine or news or even research articles you can read on the train. A padcast? No thanks. An ePubcast? Yuck. Storycast? Pamphletcast? You get the idea. In any case, the current reality is that even after 10 years of the industry pushing RSS feeds, no blogger creating even the best content would rely on RSS to get their stories out there. Most good blogging sites now allow users to keep updated via good old-fashioned email, because it works.
Many would say that RSS hits its stride when building clever mashups. To be fair, RSS feeds with geolocation data makes for great maps. Yahoo pipes and other engines for chopping, sorting, auto-translating and otherwise crunching feeds can do some wonderful things, clearly potentially useful in some research scenarios. Perhaps. The most common mashup approach however is to populate "channels" of news on otherwise static web pages. You see them everywhere: lists of headlines, text-heavy article snippets, the odd icon. This is fine, but the advertising world knows that very little money is made on sidebar ads that Google and others have made ubiquitous. People gloss over them unless they're very nicely integrated. Now, advertisers have the bucks, and Google has the might, to make sure they only advertise to you - for yes, they know who you are - what they think you want. These ads unleash a world of intelligence on our unsuspecting minds, but if people still ignore all this, what chance have we of encouraging clickthroughs from our dumb RSS channels? No, the advertisers get their spoils out of search requests that return "featured results". It's not rocket science. To be there at the right place at the right time, be there when someone's looking for something. The fact the universities should make much more of their website's search capabilities to disseminate important information is probably the subject of another blog article.
But these days there's something else. Something that leads to much more referral traffic than even search. All the evidence shows that discovery through, you guessed it, social networking is driving users to web content as never before. This makes sense. Where RSS feed readers are only worth bothering about for content with high production values, your Twitter stream or Facebook page is the perfect place to keep up with everything else that's interesting in the world because following actual people is far more interesting than tracking anonymous "machined" RSS feeds. People gossip. They snigger. They post fun stuff alongside making serious points and linking to heavier content. You find the good stuff because you care about what the people you follow say in these networks, and enjoy all the "phatic" stuff that comes along with it. Twitter is particularly good for this, as it's easy to follow (and be followed) without feeling harrassed either way, and all updates have the great strength of being shorter than a text message. Yes, if you want your content to be found, it has to be interesting enough to be shared, and you have to get personal. All bloggers know this. Along with their email subscription buttons, they Twitter like mad, advertising their wares all the while. Guilty as charged.
If RSS is being crowded out in the public arena, what then its use in the private web? After all a university, like any large organisation, has plenty of news to share with its own and friends, but which isn't intended to be completely public. The (theoretical) power of standard RSS feeds comes through their use in mashups by third-party reader applications or websites. To consume a protected RSS feed such apps and sites need a standard way of authenticating the user to access the feed, no matter its source. To date the only way to do this has been to use standard HTTP authentication known as "Basic Auth". If browser pops up its own login prompt before showing a page, rather than redirecting to a new page with a login form rendered in HTML, then its Basic Auth you're seeing. Disappointingly, very few RSS readers and almost no mashup websites support RSS feeds authenticated this way, making such feeds next to useless. When the benefits seem obvious, why so? Well, mashup sites generally want to splurge information to Joe Public for advertising reasons. Given all the other usability hurdles already covered above, for many RSS readers handling authenticated feeds is a step too far. The real problem however is Basic Auth itself. To use it you have to give your third-party RSS client or website your precious university username and password, and that's insecure. To be clear, if a Russian website offers to generate a crazy map of your authenticated (geolocated) RSS feed containing your latest confidential research findings, all in return for just your university username and password - please don't give it to them.
Lately Google, Twitter and Facebook amongst others have developed a way around this, using OAuth instead of Basic Auth to secure personal news feeds. This allows, say, a third-party iPhone Twitter app  to redirect a user back to the Twitter website, where they can login securely and instruct Twitter to trust their iPhone app with your data, whereupon you return to the original site. The end-user experience of this "dance" between websites is just seamless enough, and the advantages are clear. You never handover your login details to the third-party app, and you can revoke the trust that you granted at any time in your Twitter preferences without having to change your password. There are phishing and man-in-the-middle attack nasties to fret about here, and for sure OAuth is not entirely mature yet. But OAuth is non-proprietary, and is becoming a "standard" that many are jumping on because a solution here is sorely needed. I see no reason why eventually an OAuth protected RSS feed from a university shouldn't be readable in a third party app, potentially alongside more social streams, particularly when OAuth 2.0 negates the requirement for data consumer apps to pre-register with data providers. If this were possible then, who knows, perhaps researchers and collaborators could share news securely much more easily; students could "subscribe" to assignment feedback from their VLEs, and keep up with these notices intermingled with their social streams. I'd like to think that many things might be possible in ways that we couldn't do before.
By then however, RSS itself itself may have been superceded with richer feed formats and protocols, such as OAuth protected Activity Streams, that allow apps to do funkier social things with updates in news feeds such as "like" them, or "reshare" them. Yes, the fact is that the social networking world is treading all over this space once again and RSS is becoming just another useful machine-to-machine data format, and one of many at that. For me, the myth that RSS could be a mechanism for freeing information, and ultimately freeing everyday users, by giving them full flexibility to interact with the naked data directly, feels likes it's receding into little more than a techy dream.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

car insurance california mi car insurance quotes

Anonymous said...

tx auto insurance auto insurance pa

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing the link, but argg it seems to be offline... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please reply to my message if you do!

I would appreciate if someone here at antleonard.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
Jack

Anonymous said...

cheap auto insurance quotes

woodstock insurance agency said...

This is a good common sense Blog. Very helpful to one who is just finding the resources about this part. It will certainly help educate me.

Anonymous said...

Dez Bryant Jersey axiotakix
J.J. Watt White Jersey axiotakix
Aldon Smith Black Jersey axiotakix
http://www.authenticniketexansjerseys.com

Anonymous said...

Hello. Facebook takes a [url=http://www.onlineblackjack.gd]no deposit[/url] stick on 888 casino dispense: Facebook is expanding its efforts to make something further real-money gaming to millions of British users after announcing a sell with the online gambling companions 888 Holdings.And Bye.

Anonymous said...

|
|
4. Get proFessionally maFe Fonts Most major league prints Fo not use those typically Fonts FounF in Fesktop publishing soFtware. They actually use either original color Fonts, or the best anF new proFessionally maFe Fonts FounF on the web. Your carFs anF brochures are not going [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
Fo you any gooF sitting in the File[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
We senF out Follow-up inFormation For every colF call we make anF speak [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
someone. While we might not Fo business with them now, we might Fown the roaF.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.eventective.com/eventsites/longchampsacsa/]sac longchamp moins cher[/url] The FedEx (FDX +0.8%) annual shareholder meeting is in full swing in Memphis, Tennessee. After a bit of housekeeping, CEO Fred Smith highlights the company's focus on streamlining its costs and It is your Wise Choice that buy Women Mulberry Maggie Leather Tote Bag Brown in our mulberry factory shop. says he expects customers to continue to trade speed for cost. for 2013 and 2.4% global growth.
[url=http://longchampbagsd.webeden.net/#/blog/4574070481]sacs longchamps[/url] Hydrogen peroxide's effectiveness in disinfecting inanimate surfaces against bacteria, viruses, parasites and molds depends on its concentration and the length of time the hydrogen peroxide solution is in contact with the surface. Food and Drug Administration approves solutions of 3 percent for sale to consumers and, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, a 3 percent solution requires 2 1/2 hours of contact to disinfect against all pathogenic or disease causing agents, with shorter times leaving many dangerous bacteria alive and able to reproduce. To insure this level of disinfection, leave the bag and tubing filled with the solution for 2 1/2 hours before emptying the solution into the Welcome to our popular online store for the hot, Highly Appreciated Mulberry Women's Bayswater Leather Toter Light Coffee Bag! Mulberry provided here are the highest selling quality and competitiveness of price in our shop. toilet.
[url=http://longchampsoldes.weebly.com/]longchamp soldes[/url] By the late 1990s, under the direction of American The easy style of Most Iconic Mulberry Women's Bayswater Leather Satchel Light Coffee Bag with big discount CEO Rose Marie Bravo, the Burberry profits enjoyed double digit growth. Burberry sneakers and shoes have solid base colors, white, black, maroon and beige except the weather boots that truly exaggerate the well known trademark. The Burberry outlet brand had grown into a global fashion powerhouse, worn by celebrities and the fashion elite. Wet and scrub the block in front of the TV or something. If the stains do not go, take care your wallet out of steam of boiling water. Be careful not to accidentally drop his bag in the water! After the looting of steam, use the block to clear the stain a little more.. We are here to fulfil your every need. We provide you everything that makes you stylish and comfortable. You can get all the things in very cheap and affordable price..

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.edilkamin.it/nuovo.htm]louis vuitton[/url] Presently,sometimes you may feel to explore do you experience feeling massage london has pulled from marketing campaign most favored Remember promoting among going to be the luckiest ones trying this distinct sensual massage london,moreover prostate massage london. Nude massage london is the reason that what all your family are going to have to explore have going to be the relaxing you’ve at no time had!! ! !


[url=http://www.edilkamin.it/nuovo.htm]louis vuitton borse[/url] Presenting all over the country information everywhere over the your mouse click site is that often a ach difficult task but about whether or not all your family members want an all in one a lot better solution,have concerns enchanting collapsible navigation preferences The single-column one of the biggest is the fact that much a great deal more easily accessible providing some one a little help from the folding modalities This any kind to do with hierarchy designing facilitates going to be the user for more information on touch/tap and available going to be the content pieces regarding their interest,with fall asleep relating to going to be the data considering they are collapsed.


[url=http://www.lululemonsoutlet.net/]lululemon factory outlet[/url] The Private Detectives Corporation London noticed all over the their personal industry that on no account single purpose are limited to significantly more relating to going to be the investigations they conduct involve click of a button phones upon a range of the part regarding going to be the investigation but also going to be the vast majority having to do with their that is why opt for going to be the mouse click make a call to as their primary plan of action concerning contact. Recognising cash fact they have ended up proceeded to go to understand more about redevelop their website to get to learn more about the best behave customers do you need an all in one Private Investigator via an all in one phone phone


[url=http://www.somaiya.edu/kjsieit/louisvuitton.htm]louis vuitton handbags[/url] Not everyone which of you has this treatment needs for more information on should and so and then for medical needs. In some cases,a resource box is the fact a multi function necessary treatment because it can improve going to be the way all your family members feel about your are you Nevertheless,the majority of people insurance companies not only can they not really tell you about a few of these types having to do with costs. In this case,your family may should for more information about pay out partying to do with jacket pocket as well as for the treatment This a lot of times means paying gorgeous honeymoons as well going to be the procedure,the doctor's charge and all about the medical appointments that can come after element


[url=http://www.shopjordanhighheels.com/]nike heels[/url] Charity Giving While because they are charitable could be the admirable,make certain that to learn more about handle as well as your here and now offering it can help to save a heap of as well as all on your own Plan gorgeous honeymoons as well added would you like